Dogs love to explore the world with their mouths. But before they explore your couch or shoes, be prepared with indestructible dog toys.

A heavy-duty toy will keep your dog busy and out of trouble. But how would you know which ones are tough enough? Well, our reviews and guide are here to help you. Let’s jump right in.

Benebone Real Bacon Wishbone Dog Chew Toy

Wishbone-shaped toy in three sizes made from ultra-durable nylon. It has a 100% real bacon flavor, and the shape provides a comfortable paw grip. Plus, these indestructible dog toys for chewers are made in NY, US.

Dogs love anything that resembles a bone, and these tough dog toys taste like bones, too. The brand used 100% real bacon for flavor

The bone is from tough nylon, known as the most rigid material for aggressive chewers. It comes in three sizes for different breeds. As for puppies, it’s best for those weighing around 70 lbs.

The ingredients, bone, and packaging are all made in NY, US. Plus, portions of all Benebone sales go to support animal organizations, so you’ll help more dogs by buying this toy. These are some of the most indestructible dog toys. Keep that in mind if you have a dog with weak teeth. 

Product Specifics:

  • Nylon material
  • 100% real bacon flavor
  • Made in NY, US
  • Three sizes

Pros:

  • Long-lasting & comfortable shape 
  • Engaging flavor 
  • Purchases support dog welfare organizations 

Cons:

  • Might be heavy for smaller breeds
  • Might cause tooth breakage 

Why we choose this product: We love a company that supports dog welfare organizations. Also, this bone is made from nylon, and thanks to its bacon flavor, dogs love chewing it. 

Arm & Hammer Super Treadz

An ape-shaped dog toy made from durable & natural rubber with a groovy surface. The rubber is infused with baking soda to clean the dog’s teeth and refresh their breath. It comes in two sizes with a hole for treats and is machine washable. 

Many dogs show resilience when it’s time for teeth cleaning, so it’s a great idea to have a chewable toy that supports dental care while playing. This ape-shaped toy is designed to clean tartar and plaque build-up and stimulate the gums, thanks to its baking soda-infused rubber.

The ape is made from all-natural rubber that withstands the toughest chewers. Pitbull, Labrador, and Rottweiler owners confirm that these tough dog toys are super durable. 

The product comes in two sizes — a small red gorilla and a large mint gorilla. It’s suitable for puppies over six weeks and dishwasher safe. The toy has a hole for small treats in the bottom. 

Product Specifics:

  • Sturdy & durable natural rubber 
  • Baking-soda infused
  • Treat dispenser 
  • Machine-washable

Pros:

  • Cool design
  • Cleans teeth and deodorizes breath 
  • Reduces tartar and plaque build-up 

Cons:

  • Might have an unappealing scent
  • Stiff & tight treat bottom

Why we choose this product: The gorilla-shaped design immediately caught our eye. Plus, it’s great to have chew-proof dog toys that’ll take care of your dog’s teeth and reward it with treats. And most importantly, the rubber is super-durable. 

Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Ring Chew Toy

Ring-shaped indestructible dog toys with a guaranteed lifetime warranty. The same rubber is used for building spacecraft and has a red safety alert core. It comes in four sizes and three colors. Plus, it’s easy to clean with warm water. 

This toy stands out from the rest in terms of material and longevity. For starters, these indestructible dog toys have a lifetime guarantee, so you can return the chewed-up toy and get a brand new one.

They’re made from the same rubber used for spaceships and aircraft. Also, the toys have two layers. The second (red) layer indicates when they’re close to ripping apart. It’s been tested on Labradors, Pitbulls, Great Danes, and German Shepherds, so it’s safe to say that this toy can withstand the mightiest jaws. 

The Goughnut comes in four sizes. The small and medium-size are best for moderate chewers and smaller dogs. Meanwhile, more aggressive, bigger puppies will appreciate the large and extra-large rings. These are US-made indestructible dog toys that require only warm water for cleaning. 

Product Specifics:

  • Reinforced natural rubber
  • Lifetime guarantee 
  • Made in the US
  • Four sizes

Pros:

  • 20% harder rubber
  • Red safety core
  • Lifetime guarantee
  • Ideal for playing fetch & teething dogs

Cons:

  • Heavy for small pups
  • Might have a bad smell

Why we choose this product: It’s designed by spacecraft engineers, which is a good enough reason for us to consider this toy. But that’s not all. The lifetime warranty guarantees a free toy for a torn-off one.

West Paw Zogoflex Jive Ball

A heavy-duty blue ball from BPA-free thermoplastic rubber. It comes in two sizes. The toy is made from 100% recyclable materials from the US. It floats and has a higher bounce on land. 

Every heavy chewer needs a ball that can withstand a thousand games of fetch. Since rubber balls are the most durable, West Paw designed a bouncy ball from Thermoplastic Elastomer, meaning an elastic and durable rubber. 

If you have fur friends that enjoy water games, these might be the best indestructible dog toys for you, as they stay afloat. The groovy design has a wacky bounce and fits in a standard ball thrower. 

The blue ball comes in small and large sizes. The rubber is BPA-free, 100% recyclable, and FDA-approved. It’s made in Montana, and you can machine wash it.

Product Specifics:

  • Heavy-duty thermoplastic rubber
  • BPA-free, 100% recyclable & FDA-approved 
  • Made in the US
  • Two sizes
  • Machine washable 

Pros:

  • Stays afloat
  • Higher bounce
  • Fits in a ball thrower

Cons:

  • Might be heavy for some dogs
  • Not intended for chewing

Why we choose this product: Even though they aren’t the best indestructible dog ball toys for chewing, the design is perfect for a classic game of fetch (even in water). Plus, the heavy-duty rubber is BPA-free. 

KONG® Extreme Dog Toy

A fetch-toy for aggressive chewers made in the US from natural, heavy-duty black rubber. It comes in five sizes, with holes at the bottom for stuffing treats. The toys are also machine washable. 

This toy has had the support of veterinarians, trainers, and dog owners for over forty years. It’s from a natural rubber formula — the toughest one the company has ever made. 

The toy works great for anxious dogs that chew aggressively anything that comes in their way. Also, it’s excellent for games of fetch as it bounces unpredictably. What’s more, you can stuff treats at the toy’s bottom. 

These indestructible dog toys are suitable for Labs and Rottweilers’ jaws. But they’re also soft enough to prevent tooth breakage. They come in five sizes, depending on a dog’s age and weight. According to most dog owners, the L size works fine with most pups. The toy is machine washable and made in the US

Product Specifics:

  • Natural rubber formula
  • Treat dispenser 
  • Five sizes
  • US-made 
  • Machine-washable 

Pros:

  • Mentally stimulating toy
  • Heavy-duty rubber without tooth breakage 
  • Unpredictable bounce

Cons:

  • Treats might fall off the toy
  • Doesn’t float

Why we choose this product: It has had the trust of veterinarians, trainers, and dog owners for over forty years, and we can see why. These nearly indestructible dog toys have a unique shape of sturdy natural rubber. Also, you can fill them with treats. 

Nero Ball Ultra™

A heavy-duty rubber ball attached to a nylon rope. It comes in one size, and it’s an excellent reward toy used by military dogs. The rope throws the ball at a great distance, and the non-slip handle is great for tug-of-war. 

Many dog owners use reward toys when their pooch is good and obedient. If you have a strong chewer that’ll appreciate a toy more than a treat, this is the best indestructible reward toy for you. 

It’s a ball from firm wavy rubber attached to a strong nylon rope with a non-slip handle. The toy is quite tough and used by police K-9 and military dogs

Plus, you don’t need to carry a ball thrower for this toy, as the rope launches it at an incredible distance. It comes in one size, with an orange ball and a blue rope.

Product Specifics:

  • Orange rubber ball with blue nylon rope
  • Used as a reward toy by police K-9 and military dogs
  • Wavy design 

Pros:

  • Tough & portable
  • No need for a ball thrower 
  • Holds up powerful jaws

Cons:

  • Not a chew toy
  • Not a durable rope

Why we choose this product: These tough dog toys are powerful enough to withstand the strong teeth of police K-9 and military dogs. Also, it’s a great toy for a game of fetch or tug-of-war. 

Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Dog Pull Toy

Tug-of-war toy made from natural rubber. It’s designed for large dogs with powerful jaws. This US toy has a figure-eight design and comes in one size.

Tug-of-war is dogs’ favorite game, but it requires a strong enough toy for pulling and biting. And this one is among the best indestructible tug of war dog toys for large dogs on the market. 

The figure-eight design is made in the US from natural rubber with engineered carbon reinforcement. It has one size in black with red dots. 

Dog owners give this toy to their pets to play with each other. They report that it can successfully survive the strong jaws of two Cane Corsos.

Product Specifics:

  • Figure-eight design 
  • Natural rubber with carbon reinforcement
  • Made in the US
  • One size for large dogs 

Pros:

  • Low chance of getting bitten 
  • Great for dog-on-dog tug-of-war

Cons:

  • Strong smell
  • Not intended for chewing

Why we choose this product: These indestructible dog tug toys hold up the bite force of the mightiest chewers, all thanks to the heavy-duty rubber. The shape triggers dogs’ competitive side, allowing them to test their strength. 

Ethical Pets “S” Bone

Curved bone-shaped toy from a heavy-duty thermoplastic material for large & giant dog breeds. The bone has a hollow center for treats and floats on water. 

Thermoplastic material (TPR) is a strong synthetic rubber that resists tear and abrasion, so it’s an excellent choice for dog toys. This TPR toy has a bright red color guaranteed to grab your dog’s attention. 

Since they come in one size only, these are the best indestructible rubber dog toys for large & giant dog breeds. Many Pitbull, Great Dane & Labrador owners confirm that the rubber is truly durable. 

The toy floats on water, so it’s excellent for indoor and outdoor play. Also, it has a hollow center for treats, so it can help with that weight-loss program. 

Product Specifics:

  • Thermoplastic rubber 
  • Bright red curved design
  • For large & giant dog breeds
  • Hollow center for treats

Pros:

  • Exercise & stimulate the brain
  • Great for weight loss
  • Floats on water 

Cons:

  • Might be heavy for some breeds
  • No size options

Why we choose this product: TPR makes some of the best indestructible chew dog toys. It’s durable and bouncy. Also, the rubber floats, so it’s great for outdoor adventures, and there’s a place for treats, too.

Tuffy Barnyard Rabbit Squeaker

Indestructible dog toys with squeakers in two sizes and two color options. They’re filled with polyester, have four layers of cross-stitched materials, and are outlined with reinforced binding. Also, the toys float on water and are machine washable. 

TUFFY toys are a collection of fleece animals designed for interactive play. You can find these nearly indestructible dog toys on Amazon in a pack of two or a single toy with two size options — small and regular. 

The rabbit toy ranks 9/10 on the company’s scale for toughness. It’s cross-stitched, made with four layers of materials, and has a black binding for added durability. Also, it’s soft and light due to the poly filling. 

You can choose between a white or brown rabbit, which floats on water. Plus, the toy is safe for the washing machine (air dry). These are durable dog squeaky toys, with the squeaker sewn in protective pouches. 

Product Specifics:

  • Fleece rabbit toy 
  • Four layers of cross-stitched material with a binding
  • Filled with polyester
  • Squeaker 

Pros:

  • Safely sewn squeaker
  • Floats on water 
  • Heavy-duty stitching 

Cons:

  • Weak ears
  • Not intended for chewing  

Why we choose this product: This toy resembles the classic stuffed animal but with added durability. The four layers are cross-stitched multiple times and protected with a reinforced binding. 

Outward Hound Fire Biterz Lizard Squeaky Dog Toy

A popular choice from Outward Hound’s collection of indestructible dog toys from a fire hose material. The lizard is red and comes in two sizes. You’ll find squeakers inside the toy for extra fun. It has no stuffing & it’s easy to rinse and clean. 

Outward Hound designs squeaker animal toys from a real fire hose material. Since the company makes these toys in many shapes and sizes, we’ve decided to pick the most popular one i.e the lizard. The toy comes in two sizes and its material is in striking red color.

If you’re looking for stuffed animal toys, these lizards might not be the best choice for indestructible fabric dog toys, as they’re stuffing-free. But with these, you won’t have to clean up the potential mess. 

The toys are outlined with a unique K9 Tuff guard bidding and are great for a game of hide & seek or fetch.

Product Specifics:

  • Fire hose squeaker toy
  • Two sizes
  • No stuffing
  • K9 Tuff guard bidding

Pros:

  • No stuffing, no mess
  • Durable material

Cons:

  • Not a chewing toy
  • Doesn’t float

Why we choose this product: We’re fond of Outward Hound’s fantastic animal collection. Their lizard design is attention-grabbing, squeaky, and from an actual fire hose material.

KONG Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy

A red frisbee toy made from strong and flexible rubber. It’s made in the US and comes in two sizes. The toy is specifically designed to maintain dogs’ teeth. However, since it’s slightly heavier, it doesn’t float on water.

KONG designed this frisbee specifically for a nice game of fetch with your furry pal. It’s made of heavy-duty rubber that should last longer than regular plastic frisbees. 

These red Petco indestructible dog toys have a pattern that maintains dogs’ teeth. Also, the rubber is flexible enough to fold entirely, and it won’t cause any injuries due to its softness. 

The KONG frisbees are heavier than regular ones, so they sink in water. Still, the heaviness provides a more accurate throw. The toys are made in the US and come in S and L sizes. 

Product Specifics:

  • Heavy-duty rubber
  • Red color 
  • Size S & L
  • Made in the US

Pros:

  • The soft rubber provides a safer catch
  • Maintains dental health
  • Flexible & compact 

Cons:

  • Can’t fly as far as regular frisbees
  • Doesn’t float

Why we choose this product: The rubber of this frisbee won’t cause any injuries to you or your dog. Plus, it’ll take care of your pooch’s teeth. Also, the Kong indestructible dog toys are famous for their sturdy rubber material. 

NOUGAT Squeaky Dog Chew Toys

A crocodile-shaped toy made from 100% eco-friendly and natural rubber. These toys are available in M & L size, and are the best indestructible dog toys for medium and large dogs. Also, the toys have a built-in squeaker and bristles for dental support.

Dogs love squeaky toys, and pet parents love toys that’ll clean their dog’s teeth. So here’s a match made in heaven. These indestructible dog toys have a built-in squeaker and are made of 100% natural BPA-free rubber

The bumpy texture and added bristles help to clean dogs’ teeth and reduce tartar. You can even add toothpaste around the bristles for a more effective clean or peanut butter for a delicious playtime. 

The toy has milk flavor, and the company tested it on Retrievers, German Shepherds, and Labradors. It comes in M&L size, in red or green. These indestructible dog chew toys have a cleaning brush and a lifetime replacement service.

Product Specifics:

  • 100% eco-friendly, natural, BPA-free rubber
  • Built-in squeaker
  • Size M&L
  • Green and red 
  • Bumpy texture & bristles

Pros:

  • Maintains dogs’ teeth
  • Life replacement service
  • Reduces destructive behavior

Cons:

  • Might be heavy for some breeds
  • Might not squeak 

Why we choose this product: The toys have a cool crocodile shape that squeaks upon chewing. Also, their rubber is strong & BPA-free, while the bumpy pattern supports dental care. 

How to Choose the Best Hard Chew Toys for Dogs

With thousands of products on the market, it’s challenging to choose the best dog toy for heavy chewers. Hopefully, our guide will spare you time, save your money, and amuse your fluffy chewer.

A Guide Toward the Best Choice 

Here are a couple of essential aspects to keep in mind if you don’t know what chew toy will cover your dog’s needs. 

Toy Material & Hardness

The favorites among owners of heavy chewers are rubber and nylon. Apart from being heavy-duty, they’re safe chewing toys for dogs as the material is soft enough to not cause harm. Another popular option is rope toys, but swallowing large quantities of fiber might be dangerous. Latex and vinyl toys aren’t incredibly heavy-duty, so they’re best for mild to moderate chewers. Lastly, most plush or fleece toys aren’t anywhere near indestructible, and aggressive chewers tear them up in seconds.

Dog Size & Breed

If you want your dog to enjoy playtime safely with a long-lasting toy, the size and breed of your pooch are crucial. A perfect toy for smaller dogs is light enough for them to carry around and big enough so they can’t swallow it. In contrast, the best indestructible big dog toys should be heavier, bigger, and tougher to withstand the dog’s strong jaws. 

Product Guarantee & Refund

Indestructible dog toys should withstand aggressive playtime and heavy chewings. Apart from guaranteeing long-lasting & durable design, consider toys that are BPA-free and FDA-approved. What’s more, many companies offer money refunds, and some have a lifetime replacement guarantee if the toy gets damaged.

Shape & Design

Don’t waste money on a toy your pooch won’t even like to smell and acknowledge your dog’s playing habits. For bone lovers, bone toys feel and taste great. For playing fetch, you can find excellent heavy-duty balls and frisbees. Finally, there are excellent toys for tug-of-war, as well as squeaky and plush toys to choose from. 

Toy’s Purpose

For dogs that like to play with you or another dog, look for the best indestructible rope dog toys, frisbees, balls, or tug-of-war toys. But if your dog enjoys playing alone, go for chewing toys, like bones, squeaker toys, or stuffed animals. 

Ease of Cleaning 

Dog toys are usually easy to maintain, requiring only water to rinse off the excess dirt and saliva. Still, toys tend to gather bacteria, especially the ones with treat dispensers. For a proper clean, look for toys that are safe for the dishwasher or the washing machine. 

What’s an Indestructible Dog Toy and How Does It Work?

Puppy chew toys are strong enough to withhold the wear and tear of aggressive chewers. So even though they’re not 100% indestructible, they can add to playtime fun for a long time. 

The difference between a regular and tough toy is that the latter is heavier, larger, and incredibly difficult to chew. They come in various shapes and sizes, and some even have a place for treats, too. Since the purpose of these toys is heavy-chewing, many have a unique pattern that cleans the dogs’ teeth and gums.

Types

There are all kinds of heavy-duty toys with exciting shapes, cool patterns, and catchy colors. Let’s see the six most common types of indestructible dog chew toys:

  • Dog Balls are mainly made for a game of fetch and provide a higher, unpredictable bounce. These toys are of similar size to tennis balls but usually a lot heavier. 
  • Dog Bones are for chewing purposes. Some come with a flavor, while others have treat dispensers. Their shape supports a comfortable paw grip. 
  • Treat Toys usually have holes for treats on the bottom. They aim to be both mentally and physically stimulating. 
  • Squeaker Toys have a noise-making device inside that triggers dogs to find it. The best indestructible squeaky dog toys should have a safely layered squeaker, so the dog can’t pull it out and eat it.
  • Plush Toys are usually animal dog toys filled with polyester. They’re soft, light, and very flexible. For added durability, these toys are sewn with several layers of material, double-stitched, and outlined with a binding.
  • Interactive Toys like tug-of-war toys & frisbees are excellent for playing with you or other dogs.

Cost Details — Is an Indestructible Dog Toy Worth the Price?

Cheap indestructible dog toys range from $5 to $20. They usually get torn off in a couple of days because the materials are durable but not long-lasting enough. Still, not all cheap versions are useless. You can find excellent nylon and rubber toys that are better than most high-priced toys on the market.

Dogs tend to get easily bored, so you might need multiple toys to keep them entertained. Luckily, you can get the best dog subscription box that takes care of your pooch by sending treats and toys on a regular or monthly basis. 

The pricey tough toys that can survive wear and tear are around $20 to $35. Also, plush toys cost more since their material is the least durable one. Expensive, tough dog toys also offer different sizes & colors, as well as a refund or replacement guarantee. 

Aggressive chewers tend to be highly energetic, so you may also consider some dog treadmill options that guarantee a high level of activity.

At a Glance — Summarizing Our Best Top Indestructible Dog Toys

Benebone Real Bacon Wishbone Dog Chew Toy: Best flavored toys

Arm & Hammer Super Treadz: Best indestructible toy design

Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Ring Chew Toy: Best chewable ring toys

West Paw Zogoflex Jive Ball: Best thermoplastic ball toys

KONG® Extreme Dog Toy: Best KONG toy for treats

Nero Ball Ultra™: Best reward dog toys

Goughnuts Virtually Indestructible Dog Pull Toy: Best indestructible dog pull toys

Ethical Pets “S” Bone: Best thermoplastic bones for large dogs

Tuffy Barnyard Rabbit Squeaker: Best heavy-duty fleece toys

Outward Hound Fire Biterz Lizard Squeaky Dog Toy: Best fire hose toys

KONG Rubber Flying Disc Dog Toy: Best indestructible frisbee

NOUGAT Squeaky Dog Chew Toys: Best squeaky toy for dental care

Safety Tips for Playing With Indestructible Dog Toys

An indestructible dog toy pleases dogs’ destructive behavior and lasts for a long time. But safety comes first. Keep in mind these tips next time you reward your dog with a toy: 

  • Always supervise: Nobody wants their dog to get hurt. These toys are incredibly tough and heavy to the point that they might cause an injury to your dog. So next time you give your pet a tough toy, try to play together to avoid incidents. 
  • Keep it clean: Always rinse toys with water or put them in the washing machine. They can gather a lot of bacteria, dirt, and saliva during playtime, especially if they’re indestructible treat toys for dogs.
  • Look for loose parts: They can cause a choking hazard. Inspect the toy during or after playtime to see whether any pieces are close to ripping off.
  • Consider your dog’s teeth strength: Not all dogs have equally strong teeth. So before you search for truly indestructible dog toys, ask yourself whether it’s worth the trouble if it breaks your pooch’s teeth. 

Final Thoughts: What Indestructible Dog Toy Is Best for Your Dog? + Our Top Pick

To keep up with your dog’s aggressive chewing habits, you need a durable toy.

Look for one that won’t be pulled or ripped apart in seconds and will keep your dog busy for an extended period, like the Benebone’s wishbone toy

These are indestructible dog toys for aggressive chewers with an irresistible bacon flavor. Also, the wishbone shape has a paw-friendly grip. The nylon material provides long-lasting fun of fetch and tug-of-war. Plus, by buying this product, you’ll donate part of your money to animal welfare organizations

Many of these tough toys also maintain your dog’s teeth. But sometimes, that’s not enough. For best results, consider getting dental chews for dogs that guarantee healthy dental care.

FAQ

Can you make a DIY dog chew toy and how?

Of course, but you should always supervise your dog with it for safety. For example, you can wrap a T-shirt around a plastic bottle or make a braided toy from old towels. Also, you can come up with a tossable toy by putting a tennis ball into a sock.

Do indestructible dog toys really exist? 

It depends on the dog’s size, breed, and strength. Still, many manufacturers come close to designing nearly indestructible dog toys. The toughest ones are made from nylon, but we strongly advise you to be careful with these as some might break off your dog’s teeth. 

What is the safest toy for a dog to chew on?

Rubber toys are currently the safest toys on the market. The best ones are made from natural BPA-free rubber. These indestructible dog toys are flexible and soft enough to not cause damage but durable to withstand rough chewing.

Previous articleNo More Joint Pain — The Best Orthopedic Dog Beds of 2021
Next articlePitsky Breed Guide — Temperament, Diet, and Health Issues
Avatar for Monika Lazarevska
Nothing can stop Monika from petting a fluffy cat, even if it's in the middle of the street. She has experience with all kinds of pets — dogs, chickens, parrots, fish, bunnies, and even wolf cubs! Apart from her unconditional love for animals, she’s a creative individual that can easily lose track of time while painting. After getting a degree in English Language and Literature, Monika looked for a way to share her inspiration with others and found one in content writing.